Amazon Book Rentals vs. Your Public Library

Apparently Amazon is looking into opening a lending library for digital books--for a fee. Sort of. It would be part of their Amazon Prime membership, which currently runs $79/year and also includes two-day shipping and video streaming. Today's Publishers Weekly news blog wonders whether this service might signal big problems for public libraries.

Amazon seems to be early in the planning stages so who knows if it will actually happen, but I'm not exactly sure what the point is or whether it's a viable idea. Don't most public libraries now offer digital collections to card holders for free?

I also think it's interesting that some publications are referring to this possible new Amazon service as "Netflix for Books." Hmmm ,where have I heard that before? BookSwim, another book rental service, has been touting itself as a Netflix-style book rental service for years. I tried BookSwim not once, but twice, while I lived in an area that did not have a good public library system, and my conclusion was that other than the fact that their product arrived (eventually) via mail, they were nothing like Netflix. Their selection wasn't great, their queuing system was screwed up, shipping took forever, and their pricing plans were significantly higher than Netflix plans.

The combination of these factors meant that I could more cost effectively buy the books I wanted to read. In the case of BookSwim, some of these shortcomings are necessary: it's a lot more expensive to ship books than DVDs, for example. This would be a nonissue with electronic books. But the selection is a sticking point for me, and that could be just as much of a problem with renting ebooks from Amazon is with renting paper books from BookSwim.  So my reaction to Amazon being described as "Netflix for books" is, "I'll believe it when I see it."

I read a lot of books that are not available electronically, or that are way too expensive to buy in an electronic format. The subscription fee would negate the price-per-book issue, but would publishers who insist on putting price points of $18+ on ebooks agree to giving customers unlimited access to their content for a mere $79/year? Which ALSO includes shipping and streaming video? Just how much would readers be willing to pay for an electronic book subscription service if they have access to a decent public library?

Here are a couple selections from the blog post:

Though Amazon’s digital library is still in its very early stages, and though it’s yet to be seen if the idea hits roadblock getting publishers to cooperate, it’s time to speculate about the future of libraries. In 10 years, what will be the closest thing to a library? Will the image the word evokes change from the one we all once had–a person sitting quietly rapt at a table, poring over a book (either for research or pleasure) while surrounded by shelves and shelves of more books–to an image of a person, never leaving his or her house, pressing a series of buttons on a high-res Amazon tablet screen to check out a lent book, scanning the lines using the device’s backlight instead of the low ceiling lights of a library?

NOOOOOO! The specter of trading my beautiful public library in for a tablet screen will encourage me to keep donating whatever I can to my public library. But there's a big caveat in this paragraph: Amazon is just in talks with publishers and as far as I've seen, none have signed on yet. That's a huge obstacle in the way before this idea can become in any way viable.

But can local branches, many already running dry, survive if Amazon gives Prime, which is becoming more and more of a deal at $79 as it decorates its price tag with feature after feature, and its users the capability to access any book a library could provide, without having to leave one’s home? Publishers, reportedly worried that Amazon’s digital library will devalue books in the eyes of consumers, obviously have the rights to the books and can put the brakes on the plan. But once one publisher signs, and assuming it finds success, expect a flood of others to follow. And really, it’s hard to imagine a feature that puts books right in front of your nose and charges you no additional cost not taking off.

Yes, Prime is a good deal now and would be an even better deal with digital book rentals thrown in--IF that price point sticks. I think it's unlikely that the Big 6 publishing companies would sign off without a huge payout, and Amazon would have to come up with that cash somehow. Probably by raising the Prime subscription price.

Maybe I'm in denial because the idea of libraries failing makes me shudder. The amount of weight Amazon decides to throw around to get this done, combined with the level of desperation within the major publishing companies could make this project viable. I just think it's unlikely that this service would be the end of public libraries or paper books.

RIP VI: Death of a Gossip by MC Beaton

As I mentioned yesterday, I became hooked on MC Beaton's Agatha Raisin series a couple years ago. I almost got caught up on that series, which currently spans 21 novels, earlier this year; but then I had to take a break.

Now that fall is rolling around, I decided to pick up the most recent Agatha Raisin book--the only one I hadn't read--from my library, and I also decided to get started on Beaton's other popular series about the Scottish police constable Hamish Macbeth.

For some reason Death of a Gossip is no longer in print in the US, but my library still has the first edition hardcover from 1985. I started it last night and finished it tonight.

The premise of this book is that a malicious busybody is murdered at a week-long fishing camp in Scotland. Everyone else attending the camp has a motive for murdering the obnoxious woman, but it's up to Macbeth to determine which one of them did the deed.

Although the sleepy, easygoing Hamish Macbeth has practically nothing in common with Agatha Raisin, this book has several of the hallmarks of a Beaton book. I think it would be easy to play a drinking game while reading one of these books. It would involve taking a shot ever time a character "jeers," "sneers," screams at another character, calls another character sexy, or behaves inconsistently in order to advance the plot or a subplot.

Despite these minor annoyances, which I think can be alleviated by simply not reading Beaton books in quick succession, I'm planning to keep reading this series. Macbeth's character intrigued me: I want to know more about the six younger siblings he's helping his parents support and whether he ever becomes romantically involved with the beautiful and rebellious Priscilla Halburton-Smythe. Beaton's books are also very short, very easy reads, which makes them good palate cleansers.

This was my first full-length novel for the RIP VI challenge.

Back to the Library

I stopped by the library tonight to pick up some books that had come in for me. I didn't take the time to browse because my library book situation is, once again, getting out of control. Five books were waiting for me:

• Divergent by Veronica Roth. I've seen this recommended for people who liked the Hunger Games trilogy, which I certainly did.
• Handling the Undead by John Ajvide Lindqvist. I've seen this on a few RIP VI lists and decided to give it a try.
• Pigeon English by Stephen Kelman. This is on the Man Booker shortlist, which I'm attempting to read my way through.
• Busy Body and
• Death of a Gossip by M.C. Beaton. I got hooked on the Agatha Raisin books a couple years ago, so I decided to start on the Hamish Macbeth series as well. I've already read around 70 pages of this since I picked it up tonight, so I'll probably have a review up tomorrow.

A Is for Amy Who Fell down the Stairs

We've still got quite a bit of empty wall space to fill in our house, so when I realized this week that I could buy a book of Edward Gorey posters online, I jumped at the chance.

Once I saw that the book included this poster, how on earth could I resist?

This one is from Gorey's best-known work, the Gashlycrumb Tinies (the whole book's available at that link), which "tells the tale of 26 children (each representing a letter of the alphabet) and their untimely deaths in rhyming ... couplets, accompanied by the author's distinctive black and white illustrations.... Far from illustrating the dramatic and fantastical childhood nightmares, these scenarios instead poke fun at the banal paranoias that come as a part of parenting" (Wikipedia).

But Gorey didn't spend all of his time thinking about all the ways children could die. Here are a few of my other favorites from the book:

Innocence, on the Bicycle of Propriety, carrying the Urn of Reputation safely over the Abyss of Indiscretion

Beware of this and that

Donald imagined things

The book includes thirty 10x14 posters, so we'll have fun deciding which ones to hang and which rooms to put them in.

New Books

I got seven new books in the mail today. Most of them are work-related, but a few are just for fun.

Work-related books
I recently read a post about the five must-read books for bloggers over at Freelancing Help. I'm planning to launch a blog for my business in the next few weeks, so I was very interested in this list. As it turned out, one didn't appeal to me or seem applicable and one was available to test-drive from my public library. The remaining three looked valuable, weren't available at my library, and as I mentioned before my town is quickly running out of local bookstores (even the chain types), so I ordered them online:

• Launch: How to quickly propel your business beyond the competition by Michael A. Stelzner
• Clout and the Art and Science of Influential Web Content by Colleen Jones
• The Accidental Creative: How to be brilliant at a moment's notice by Todd Henry

I'm also branching out from my previous profession as strictly a technical writer to try my hand at journalism. But, as I've discovered, journalism is a whole different ballgame from technical writing, so I've been educating myself partly by jumping right in and partly by reading lots of books. Today's delivery included Journalism Next by Mark Briggs. It mostly covers journalism on the internet, which is what I'm most interested in.

Fun books
I've been wanting to read Les Miserables for quite awhile. I finally did some research into which translation was the best and settled on the most recent one by Julie Rose. I'm hoping to read this by the end of the year--I've seen the musical several times and it seems like a very fall-ish story.

I also picked up Born to Buy by Juliet B. Schor. I plan to have kids someday and would like to have a better idea of what makes their little brains tick. Some of the marketing that's currently aimed at kids horrifies me and I hope if I know more about it, I'll be better equipped to deal with it when my kids are the ones being marketed at.

Finally, we've lived in our house for over two years now and still have lots of bare walls. So I picked up an Edward Gorey poster book. It's got the "A is for Amy who fell down the stairs" illustration, which I'm totally hanging in my office!

RIP VI: Maigret's Christmas (Short Stories)

At the library on Wednesday night, I stumbled across a book of short stories: Maigret's Christmas by Georges Simenon. It'd been years--ten, at least--since I'd read a Maigret novel, which I remember enjoying but just never got around to picking up another one.

I'm glad I found this book. I've read the first two (of nine) stories, and it's quite a refreshing change from the Scandinavian crime fiction I've become so fond of. Rather than the dysfunctional relationships so common to Scandinavian crime fiction, Maigret and Madame Maigret have a loving, supportive relationship, and I enjoy the juxtaposition between cozy scenes of family life, with Madame Maigret knitting on the sofa; and scenes more typical to detective fiction. On the other hand, there are few if any women  in positions of power in the first two stories--the one woman who's managed to hold down any kind of job is portrayed to be cold and dishonest--so I might want to ration my Maigret lest I find myself screaming at Simenon while reading in public to write a strong female character already.

Anyway, the first story is called "Maigret's Christmas" and it's about a little girl who is known for her honesty and claims that Father Christmas has climbed into her bedroom through the window. As evidence of her claim, she has suddenly acquired a large, very expensive doll, which she says Father Christmas gave her. Her aunt, with whom she is living because her mother has died, is unwilling to investigate the little girl's claims, which obviously makes Maigret suspicious. But a neighbor who happened to be in the apartment when the little girl made her claim helps ensure that Maigret investigates--and eventually solves--the case.

This story was particularly heart-wrenching because of Madame Maigret's lack of, and longing for, a child of her own. She is clearly beyond child-bearing age, and although it's never explained, she was probably unable to have babies. Even before she's met the little girl, Madame Maigret becomes very attached to and concerned about her. According to the book, "Many of these stories feature observant and resourceful children, frightened yet resolute, who bring out a paternal streak in the childless Maigret." But in this story, it's Madame Maigret who is clearly more affected by a child in need, and the ending is somewhat unsatisfactory because the child's fate remains unclear.

The second story, "Seven Little Crosses in a Notebook," doesn't actually feature Maigret; instead, its hero is a switchboard operator named Lecoeur whose brother and nephew become involved in a manhunt for a killer. Once again, an endearing child, Bib, is at the center of the plot, although we hardly hear his voice until the end of the story. Bib's father has lost his job, but he's tried to keep that fact from Bib so he won't worry. However, Bib finds out when he tries to visit his father at his previous place of employment and ends up chasing a killer through the streets of Paris so he can get the reward money that's being offered and help his father.

The second story is quite a bit more intense than the first. Once again, the only female character is unsavory. We don't even get Madame Maigret in this story. I wonder if there will be any likable female characters in this book, other than Madame Maigret? I don't remember whether there were any in the last Maigret novel I read.

A note about the translation: I don't know if the same translator (Jean Stewart) has done all the Maigret books, but as a former French student, I thought it was interesting that she occasional seems to have kept the French syntax in the English translation. I had to slow down a few times and reread a few passages because the syntax was slightly different from what I'm used to, but I enjoyed that because I think it added to the French flavor of the stories. Unfortunately I didn't keep note of examples while reading, but I'll try to for the rest of the stories.

This book seems not to be in print anymore, but it's worth picking up from a library if you can find it.

To the Library

We decided to brush the dust off our bikes last night and ride downtown to the library. Unfortunately the lovely cool temperatures we've had for the past few days are now a thing of the past--temporarily, anyway. We also had to deal with thick swarms of gnats on the way there and I probably inhaled more than I care to think about. It's only 6.5-mile round trip, though, and the ride home was much more pleasant.

I think I did pretty well:

• Maigret's Christmas by Georges Simenon. I've been wanting to read these short stories for a few years and thought the RIP VI challenge would be a good reason to pick it up again. I started the first story at the library and can tell that I'm really going to enjoy these stories. It's been several years since I've read a Maigret book and I'd forgotten how good they are.
• Ruined by Paula Morris. I actually reserved this before I found out about the RIP challenge, but I think it'll be a good fit. It also takes place in New Orleans! We took a trip there last winter and I've been keeping my eyes open for books set there ever since.
• Mr. Peanut by Adam Ross. I've heard Ann mention this book on Books on the Nightstand a few times, so when I saw it on the shelf tonight, I decided it was time to give it a go. It should also be good for the RIP challenge. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel described it as "Sophisticated, surreal and creepy."
• How to Bake a Perfect Life by Barbara O'Neal. I saw Jenny Hansen raving about Barbara O'Neal and decided to give her a try.
• A Brief Guide to the Modern Library by Colm Toibin and Carmen Callil. This is another one of those books that's basically a list of novels. I'm actually thinking about a post about this book, and other book lists, later this week.
• The Queen of New Beginnings by Erica James. I just saw this on the shelf and thought it looked entertaining.